Doxis Blog  ECM & Archive

Supplier audit checklist: 8 steps to run one right

| Marc Volquardsen

A smiling man in a sweater sitting at a laptop, with a supplier audit checklist graphic to the left.

 

A supplier problem rarely announces itself. It shows up as a defect on your production line, a late shipment you only hear about once it's already late, or a certificate that turns out to be expired against your quality management standards.

By then, the cost has already moved from the supplier's side of the relationship to yours.

In automotive, a Deloitte point-of-view paper from 2026 notes that recalls among the top 10 selling vehicle manufacturers in the US rose from 286 in 2024 to 345 in 2025.

It also observes that OEMs are shifting more recall and warranty costs to suppliers through indemnification clauses.

A structured audit is how you catch the gap before it reaches that point.

This checklist walks through the eight stages of a supplier audit that holds up: setting scope and criteria, running the audit itself, and turning the findings into corrective action your supplier follows through on.

Key takeaways

  • A supplier audit compares a supplier's actual performance against your agreed standards, using a fixed set of criteria you apply consistently.
  • The eight-step process below covers scope and scheduling through to final corrective measures.
  • EU and German due diligence law has loosened since this checklist first published: CSDDD now applies only to the largest companies from 2029, and Germany's LkSG reporting duty is being wound down. The case for auditing suppliers didn't loosen with it.
  • Audit teams are shifting from once-a-year sampling toward continuous monitoring, with AI taking on more of the document review and control testing.
  • An electronic supplier file keeps every audit plan, checklist, and report in one place, and produces the paper trail auditors and customers both ask for.

For how audits fit into ongoing supplier management, including selection, onboarding, and performance tracking, read our guide to the process. This article is the step-by-step "how".

Why supplier audits still matter, even as the legal pressure eases

The compliance case for supplier audits has changed since 2023, and it's worth being honest about how.

Rule Before Now
EU CSDDD: who is covered Three phased tiers, the smallest reaching companies with 1,000+ employees One tier: EU companies with more than 5,000 employees and more than €1.5 billion worldwide turnover, and non-EU companies with more than €1.5 billion EU turnover (met in two consecutive financial years)
EU CSDDD: timing First obligations from 2027 Omnibus I entered into force on 18 March 2026. Member states transpose by 26 July 2028, and the first obligations apply from 26 July 2029
Germany's LkSG: reporting to BAFA Annual report required BAFA stopped reviewing reports in autumn 2025. A bill in the Bundestag would cancel the duty retroactively to January 2023
Germany's LkSG: risk analysis and documentation Required Still required

Only the paperwork sent to BAFA is disappearing. The duty to run risk analyses, document findings, and act on them stays on the books. Our Supply Chain Act guide covers the original LkSG obligations in detail.

For most manufacturers, that turns the audit from a legal checkbox into a choice.

The businesses that keep auditing are doing it for the reasons that never depended on the law: knowing your supply base before a quality problem reaches your production line, walking into a customer's own audit with a clean record already on file, and having grounds to renegotiate or replace a supplier that isn't performing.

A supplier audit still supports:

  • Supplier selection: picking the right provider before you commit to them
  • Ongoing assessment: comparing and developing the suppliers you already work with
  • Quality assurance: finding the specific process gap behind a quality slip
  • ISO 9001: the standard requires you to evaluate and monitor your suppliers and keep documented evidence. Audits are one common way to do that within a working quality management system

Run audits on a set schedule, not only when something has already gone wrong. Regular audits catch problems early and build a running record of how each supplier is trending over time.

 

Guide to leaner purchase-to-pay processes

Learn how automation can make P2P processes more efficient and accelerate ROI.

Download whitepaper now

Types of supplier audits

Supplier audits break down two ways: by who carries them out, and by what they cover. A real audit combines one from each.

Who audits What it means
First-party The supplier audits themselves
Second-party You, as the customer, audit the supplier directly
Third-party An independent certifying body audits the supplier on your behalf
What's audited What it means
Product audit Checks product quality specifically
System audit Assesses the supplier's entire management system and general performance
Process audit Checks the operational procedures and workflow steps behind the work

Many ongoing supplier relationships rely on second-party audits: you auditing the supplier directly, product and process combined. Third-party audits typically come in where a certification requires an independent body.

Checklist for a supplier audit: How an audit works

Prepare carefully, run the audit consistently, then evaluate and track the results. Here are the eight steps.

1. Define the framework conditions and set the schedule

Before you start, settle the organizational details:

  • How often will you audit this supplier, and at what intervals
  • Who runs the audit: an internal or external auditor
  • Which supplier is next, and what's the specific purpose this time
  • What access you need: documents, site visits, or both

Audits are usually announced and carried out on site. Agree a date early and communicate scope and duration in advance.

Unannounced audits are also an option. They show you how a supplier performs day to day rather than how they perform when they know you're coming, but repeated unannounced visits can damage the working relationship. Desktop audits skip the site visit entirely and check documents and certifications only, useful for lower-risk suppliers or interim checks between full audits.

2. Set the criteria for the audit

Define binding audit criteria and communicate them to your suppliers in advance. Build a standard catalog so you can compare results across suppliers and over time. Criteria to consider:

  • On-time delivery: are deliveries made on schedule
  • Complaints management: how complaints get handled
  • Site conditions: infrastructure and working conditions at the supplier's site
  • Information security: how data is processed and protected
  • Technical equipment: machine condition and maintenance schedules
  • Production planning: how well production is planned
  • Employee qualification: competence and training of the supplier's staff
  • Sustainability: whether environmental standards are met

3. Create an audit plan and checklists

Collect the relevant documents first: contracts, prior audit reports, and any written agreements specific to this supplier.

Write an audit plan that records the exact procedure, the individual steps, and the focus areas. If you're checking occupational safety or logistics specifically, note that here. Then build an audit checklist: the actual set of questions and assessment points you'll work through on the day.

4. Hold a kick-off meeting

Before the audit starts, meet briefly with the supplier. Explain what will happen, why you're running the audit, and what's in it for both sides. A short kick-off meeting means nobody is caught off guard once the audit begins.

5. Conduct the audit

Record the current state and compare it against the target state you defined in step 2. Work through your checklist systematically, and check performance against each criterion using surveys, document review, and direct observation.

Document everything, especially every deficiency and non-conformance. An audit finding that isn't written down doesn't exist when you get to the report.

6. Create an audit report

The audit report is your certificate of inspection: results, a grade, and a record you can compare against future audits. Design your own assessment scale, but keep it logical and consistent, or comparisons across audits stop meaning anything.

Include in the report:

  • General information about the company audited
  • Key appointment details: date, auditor name
  • Overall results and grade
  • Detailed description of deviations and non-conformances
  • Evidence where possible, such as photos
  • Concrete improvement suggestions

7. Hold a post-mortem

Meet with the supplier again after the audit to discuss the results. Use this meeting to identify what needs to improve and agree next steps, with binding deadlines for fixing anything you flagged.

8. Develop measures

The supplier develops and implements the activities needed to close the gaps you found. Where several issues point to the same root cause, a coordinated catalog of measures works better than fixing each one separately.

This is also the point to look inward: should you change something in your own process to make the relationship work better? If the deficiencies are serious enough, is it time to look for a different supplier? How the supplier responds during the follow-up tells you a lot about whether the relationship is worth investing in further.

AI is changing what "periodic" means

Deloitte calls agentic AI the "mega hot topic" for internal audit in 2026, and its State of AI in the Enterprise survey found that 74% of companies expect to be using agentic AI within two years.

In audit practice, that shows up as teams handing more document review and control testing to AI, and moving away from the traditional once-a-year, sample-based model toward continuous monitoring, where more of a supplier's activity gets checked as it happens.

A full system audit every few years still has its place, and your smaller, focused checks are increasingly becoming an ongoing part of the relationship too.

How SEW-EURODRIVE achieved an ROI of 336%

Forrester Consulting studied the total economic impact of Doxis Intelligent Content Automation at our customer SEW-EURODRIVE. 

Discover the significant findings of this independent study.

Download the study

Make every supplier audit audit-proof with Doxis

Supplier audits generate a lot of paperwork: audit plans, checklists, evidence, reports, and the corrective-action trail that follows.

Losing track of any of it is the fastest way to leave a customer's audit team unimpressed, or to struggle when you need to show how you evaluate and monitor your suppliers.

A complete audit trail is what shows who did what, and when.

A document management platform such as Doxis keeps that paperwork in one place.

Every document gets assigned automatically to the correct electronic supplier file and archived in an audit-proof way, so you can pull up a supplier's full audit history in the time it takes to open the file.

Doxis Supplier Workspace brings supplier, purchase order, and delivery information together in one place, and syncs with SAP and other ERP systems through ERP integration so a new supplier automatically gets its own workspace.

Doxis iRoom adds supplier collaboration on top of that file: a virtual project room where you and your supplier exchange documents and track deadlines directly.

Share ratings and get notified once a supplier has read them, or let them submit certificates and photo evidence with automatic deadline reminders.

The same self-service model is showing up across procurement more broadly as vendor portals become standard for supplier collaboration.

It works the same way for audit evidence as it does for invoices and purchase orders.

Because audit findings can be sensitive, role-based access keeps each document visible only to the people who need it.

Together, that means fewer audit findings get lost between the site visit and the report, and more of your time goes into acting on what the audit actually found.

Automate Work. Accelerate Business.

Bring together AI, ECM, and workflow automation in one powerful enterprise platform.

Frequently asked questions about supplier audits

What is a supplier audit?

A supplier audit systematically checks whether a supplier meets legal requirements and your own company standards. Standard criteria and checklists identify strengths and weaknesses and surface where the supplier can improve.

When is a supplier audit necessary?

Supplier audits work well for selecting new suppliers and for assessing and strengthening relationships with existing ones. Run one whenever supplier quality or performance needs a closer look.

Are supplier audits mandatory?

Companies decide for themselves whether to run supplier audits. ISO 9001 requires you to evaluate and monitor your suppliers, and audits are a common way to do that. Due diligence law can still make them relevant, though the EU's CSDDD and Germany's LkSG now apply to a narrower set of companies than they did when first introduced.

How often should supplier audits be carried out?

There's no fixed rule: companies set their own frequency, and full system audits every three years is common practice. Many audit functions are now supplementing that with smaller, continuous checks on higher-risk suppliers between scheduled audits.

Are supplier audits required for ISO 9001?

Not explicitly. ISO 9001 requires documented evaluation, monitoring, and re-evaluation of your external providers. Supplier audits are one common way to meet that, alongside scorecards and questionnaires.

What's the difference between a supplier audit and supplier management?

A supplier audit is one activity within the broader discipline of supplier management, which covers the full lifecycle from selecting and onboarding suppliers through ongoing performance monitoring. The audit is how you verify performance at a point in time.

What is the difference between a first-, second-, and third-party supplier audit?

The supplier audits itself (first-party), you audit the supplier directly (second-party), or an independent certifying body audits the supplier on your behalf (third-party).

Marc Volquardsen

I am a Product Manager & Solution Architect and have been with Doxis since 2004. After 15 years as a Solution Consultant for Sales, in 2020 I switched to Product Management, where I design solutions for customers based on Doxis, SAP and Salesforce. Please feel free to contact me to talk about solutions for you!

Subscribe to Doxis News

You might also be interested in

How can we help you?

+49 (0) 30 498582-0
Please calculate 9 plus 4.

Your message has reached us!

We appreciate your interest and will get back to you shortly.

Contact us

Table of contents