Electronic signature: How to make the most of it under US and EU law
Since 2000, the federal ESIGN Act has ensured that a contract can't be denied legal effect just because it was signed electronically. The legal question is settled. The process question often isn't.
In a large organization, the electronic signature itself takes a few minutes in your provider's tool. The time is lost before and after: chasing signers, then filing the signed version in the right place.
This guide shows how to build e-signature into your document processes, from choosing a provider to preserving the evidence, using Adobe Acrobat Sign and DocuSign as examples.
Key takeaways
- A signature provider such as Adobe Acrobat Sign or DocuSign handles the signing, and your document management system organizes everything that happens before and after
- Setting the signer authentication level per document type keeps you from paying for identity verification where an email-authenticated signature is enough
- Starting the signature from the contract or employee file eliminates the back-and-forth between email and the signing tool
- A signature stays usable long after signing if its audit trail and evidence are kept with the document
- Contracts with EU counterparties follow eIDAS, which defines signature levels that US law doesn't
What is an electronic signature?
An electronic signature is any electronic sound, symbol, or process attached to or logically associated with a record and adopted by a person who intends to sign it. That's the definition in the ESIGN Act, and it covers everything from a typed name to a certificate-based signature.
In the US, two laws give e-signatures the same legal effect as handwritten ones: the federal ESIGN Act for interstate and foreign commerce, and the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA) at state level. UETA has been adopted by 49 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and the US Virgin Islands. New York applies its own Electronic Signatures and Records Act (ESRA) instead.
Unlike EU law, US law doesn't define signature tiers. What determines how well a signature holds up in a dispute is the evidence behind it: how the signer was authenticated, and whether the audit trail shows the document wasn't changed afterward.
Why electronic signature stalls in large organizations
In many companies, each department has chosen its own e-signature tool. Procurement signs in one portal, HR in another.
The result shows up during an audit or a dispute. The signed version exists, but nobody knows which account it's in, or whether it's the latest one.
The signature also breaks the process. Someone uploads the document to the provider, then downloads the signed file and files it manually. Every manual step is a chance to lose a version or miss a deadline.
Integrating electronic signature in 5 steps
Hey Doxi, how does my document management system organize my electronic signatures?
1. Standardize your e-signature software
The strength of a signature rests on how the provider authenticates signers and records the audit trail. If you also sign with EU partners, check that the provider can deliver advanced and qualified signatures under eIDAS through a qualified trust service provider.
Adobe Acrobat Sign and DocuSign are the two most widely used e-signature tools in large enterprises. Settling on one or two providers group-wide simplifies vendor contracts and, above all, the filing of signed documents.
If several departments already use different tools, take stock before you decide: which documents go through which tool, and where the signed versions end up.
2. Set the authentication level per document type
The right level depends on the risk of the signature being challenged and on the requirements of your industry. The table below gives common benchmarks to validate with your legal department.
| Document type | Common authentication level | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Internal approval | Click-to-sign after single sign-on | Low risk, signer already authenticated in your system |
| Employment contract, amendment | Email plus access code or SMS | Identified signer, document retained for years |
| High-value supplier contract | Signer identity verification | Large amounts, risk of dispute |
| Remote insurance or credit application | Identity verification plus documented consumer consent | Know-your-customer obligations and ESIGN consumer disclosure rules |
| Records requiring notarization | Electronic notarization where state law allows | Notarization requirements stay in force |
Build these rules into your processes. The level is then set by the signing workflow, and employees no longer have to decide on their own.
For consumer-facing documents, the ESIGN Act adds a specific step: if a law requires information to be given to a consumer in writing, the consumer must affirmatively consent to receiving it electronically after receiving certain disclosures.
3. Start the signature from the business file
The right starting point is the file where the document already lives: the contract file, or the employee file for an employment contract. The signers and deadlines are already there.
With Doxis, the person responsible for the contract starts the signature from that file. The document is converted to PDF and sent to your provider, Adobe Acrobat Sign or DocuSign, and the signers then sign using that provider's method.
You track progress in the contract file itself. There's no need to open the provider's portal to see where the signature stands.
4. Retrieve the signed version automatically
Once signed, the document returns to the file it came from. In Doxis, the signed version is saved to the contract document, next to the original, and the person responsible for the contract receives a task notifying them.
With Adobe Acrobat Sign, the process starts in Doxis, signing happens in Adobe's portal, and the signed document is filed in Doxis without manual intervention.
The result is a single reference version per contract, accessible to everyone authorized to see it.
5. Keep the evidence as long as the document
Certificate-based signatures, and the tamper-evident seals providers apply to signed PDFs, rely on certificates that typically expire after one to three years. The signature remains valid afterward, provided you can prove it was valid at the moment it was applied.
To do that, keep the evidence file or audit trail supplied by your provider with each signed document. Also favor long-term validation signature formats such as PAdES-LTA for PDFs, which include a timestamp.
Finally, apply the same retention period to the signed document as to its file. Under the ESIGN Act, an electronic record satisfies a legal retention requirement if it accurately reflects the original and remains accessible for the required period. The IRS, for example, requires employers to keep employment tax records for at least four years. In Doxis, retention rules are defined per document and file class, and our US guide to audit-proof archiving covers the requirements in more detail.
Document management guide
How can a DMS boost your organization’s efficiency? Which system is right for you? This practical guide helps you to find & implement the right DMS. Incl. checklists, real-life examples, etc. Read now ⯈
Signing with EU counterparties: eIDAS and the EU Digital Identity Wallet
If your organization signs contracts with parties in the EU, the eIDAS regulation applies on their side. It defines three levels of electronic signature: simple, advanced, and qualified. Only the qualified electronic signature has a legal effect equivalent to a handwritten signature, and it must come from a qualified trust service provider on the EU trusted list.
Under Regulation (EU) 2024/1183, known as eIDAS 2, every EU member state must offer at least one European Digital Identity Wallet by the end of 2026. EU customers and employees will be able to identify themselves and sign with a qualified electronic signature from that wallet.
Some organizations, particularly banks and others that require strong authentication, will then have to accept these wallets. If you operate in the EU, ask your signature provider when it will support them. With signature already built into your document processes, the change happens at the provider. Your files and retention rules stay the same.
Integrate electronic signature into your processes with Doxis
A signed version nobody can find, or evidence lost over the years: these risks come from the process around the signature. With Doxis, you start the signature from the contract or employee file, Adobe Acrobat Sign or DocuSign handles the signing, and the signed version comes back to the right place.
Doxis contract management and archiving complete the picture. Deadlines are tracked in the same file as the signed document, which is then archived securely and in compliance with retention rules.
- Signature started from the contract or employee file
- Integration with Adobe Acrobat Sign and DocuSign
- Automatic conversion to PDF before sending to the provider
- Progress tracked in the contract file
- Signed version saved with the contract, owner notified
- Retention rules defined per document class
Doxis is recognized as a Leader in the Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Document Management 2026. Request a free demo.
Automate Work. Accelerate Business.
Bring together AI, ECM, and workflow automation in one powerful enterprise platform.
FAQs about electronic signature
Is an electronic signature as valid as a handwritten signature?
Yes, for most business transactions. The ESIGN Act and state UETA laws prevent a signature or contract from being denied legal effect solely because it's electronic. A few categories are excluded, such as wills, family law matters, and court documents.
What's the difference between e-signature software and a document management system?
E-signature software gets the document signed and produces the evidence of signature. A document management system (DMS) organizes the document before and after signing, from the approval workflow to retention.
How long does an electronic signature remain valid?
The underlying certificate typically expires after one to three years. The signature remains enforceable if you can prove it was valid at the time of signing, using the provider's audit trail, a timestamp, and a long-term validation signature format.
How do you choose an e-signature tool?
First check the signer authentication options and the quality of the audit trail. If you sign with EU parties, check whether the provider offers qualified signatures under eIDAS. Then make sure it integrates with your document management system.
Can we use more than one e-signature provider?
Yes, as long as all signed documents return to the same document management system. For example, you can reserve one provider for commercial contracts and another for HR documents.
Is a US electronic signature valid outside the United States?
ESIGN and UETA govern transactions under US law. For a contract with a party abroad, check the law that applies: in the EU, for example, it's the eIDAS regulation, which recognizes three signature levels.
Which business documents can be signed electronically?
First check the signer authentication options and the quality of the audit trail. If you sign with EU parties, check whether the provider offers qualified signatures under eIDAS. Then make sure it integrates with your document management system.
Marc Volquardsen
I am a Product Manager & Solution Architect and have been with Doxis since 2004. After 15 years as a Solution Consultant for Sales, in 2020 I switched to Product Management, where I design solutions for customers based on Doxis, SAP and Salesforce. Please feel free to contact me to talk about solutions for you!
How can we help you?
+49 (0) 30 498582-0Your message has reached us!
We appreciate your interest and will get back to you shortly.